"Mix" forum: I agree we have too many forums already. However I don't think the Music forum really addresses the issue (it's really a show-and-tell sort of forum, and it works well as such).
What we don't have is a forum where people discuss issues like the ones raised in this thread:
- What other (non-CW) gear to people recommend for tracking / mixing / mastering? (Mics, pres, etc.)
- Techniques for tracking and mixing in SFP: ordering of dynamics, EQ, etc inserts; use of buses (in addition to or in lieu of individual tracks?; surround busing); how wide should cymbals be?; where should backing vocalists sit both pan-wise and reverb-wise?; how do I get the snare sound that mixer Joe Shmo got on album XYZ?; etc.
In my view it would be a forum dedicated ONLY to the recording and mixing aspects of SCOPE, including outboard gear but excluding computers and other software (Logic / Cubase / etc). It would also
not be the right forum for discussing synths and samplers!!! It would be dedicated to tracking and mixing. These issues have been neglected by the CreamWare community IMHO.
Mics and pres: I've never used a high end pre before. I've heard that even an SM57 actually sounds good through a high end mic pre. (I don't believe it for a second, mind you, but...)
Having a variety of mics is always a good thing. You can get
a cheap U87AI if you know where to look. Otherwise renting is the best approach, I think. That goes for mic pres, too.
Unfortunately in places like Canada music shops are fairly po dunk. It's pretty hard to rent decent gear -- it's always out (and overdue!). But it should be the first step, whenever possible.
If you can't find what you're looking for then take a chance and buy something.
Older gear is often in great condition and can be had for cheap. You won't get "big names" but if you know what to look for, some fantastic deals are out there.
I don't really know mic pres very well so can't comment specifically. But if you were to look for a cheap compressor that sounds good, maybe the Valley People / Allison Gain Brain (can be had for a couple hundred bucks) would be a good choice. In terms of mics, the Audio-Technica ATM25 is probably the most versatile dynamic mic for my $100, better than Sennheiser's MD421. In the effects world the Roland DEP series is incredibly cheap these days (~ $150) but they still sound fantastic.
So keep the "obscure old gear" idea in mind as an alternative to all the new flashy crap. If you buy something that's old and cheap, and it doesn't work out for you, you can usually sell it at cost. Maybe even to me!
Check out
reviews too. They can muddle ya in the short term, but once you sort out who you trust and who you don't

then sifting through the reviews becomes a lot easier.
Of course I also trust GaryB's opinion at this point

(sorry if I make you blush GaryB) and would like to try out the Manley. But I can't afford to. (Yet.

)
Must sleep.
Johann